Shielded by Politics: The Shomrim’s Political Influence in Brooklyn
The Shomrim, a volunteer neighborhood patrol operating within Brooklyn’s Orthodox Jewish communities, have long been both lauded for their community service and scrutinized for their political entanglements. Their close ties with local politicians and law enforcement have sparked debates about accountability, justice, and the balance between community autonomy and public oversight.
Origins and Purpose of the Shomrim
Established to provide an added layer of security in neighborhoods like Borough Park and Williamsburg, the Shomrim (Hebrew for “guards”) function as civilian patrols addressing minor disturbances, missing persons, and community concerns. While their presence has been reassuring to many residents, critics argue that their operations sometimes blur the lines between community service and vigilantism.
Political Connections and Support
Jacob Daskal and Community Board 12
Jacob Daskal, a prominent figure within the Shomrim, served on Brooklyn’s Community Board 12. His role gave him significant sway in local decisions and helped reinforce Shomrim’s institutional support. [Source: NYC.gov]
Mayor Eric Adams’ Engagement
Eric Adams, both during his time as Brooklyn Borough President and now as mayor, has maintained a strong alliance with the Shomrim. From public praise to funding vests and support efforts, Adams’ relationship with the group has symbolized political legitimacy. [Source: AMNY]
Senator Simcha Felder’s Advocacy
State Senator Simcha Felder has frequently collaborated with the Shomrim and vocally supported their work in helping NYPD prevent hate crimes. [Source: Twitter/X]
Congressman Jerrold Nadler’s Commendation
In a formal House statement, Congressman Nadler honored Boro Park Shomrim for bravery during local safety threats. [Source: Nadler.house.gov]
DA Charles Hynes and Allegations of Favoritism
Former Kings County DA Charles “Joe” Hynes was often accused of enabling abuse cover-ups within Brooklyn’s Orthodox community by refusing to prosecute key figures like Shomrim members. Critics claim he protected his base in exchange for political support. [Source: Wikipedia]
Controversies and Legal Challenges
The Taj Patterson Case
In 2013, Taj Patterson, a Black gay man, was assaulted in Williamsburg by individuals allegedly affiliated with the Shomrim. Patterson later won a $4.5 million settlement. [Source: The Advocate]
Jacob Daskal’s Conviction
In 2023, Daskal was sentenced to 17 years for transporting a minor for sex and abusing his power as a religious and community leader. [Source: AP News]
Related reading: Shielded by Authority: NYPD’s 66th Precinct & Shomrim Nexus
Community Dynamics and Political Aspirations
Heshy Tischler’s Political Endeavors
Tischler, an ultra-Orthodox activist and longtime Shomrim supporter, has built a political platform defending their work and discrediting critics. [Source: Spectrum News]
Explore related analysis:
- Judicial Failures in Child Abuse Cases
- Civilian Patrols: Public Safety or Parallel Justice?
- $200M Civil Suit: Daskal, Shomrim & Bobov Leaders
Conclusion
The Shomrim’s story is one of civic complexity—marked by altruism, politics, and scandal. As public trust in law enforcement fluctuates, scrutiny of parallel justice systems like Shomrim becomes essential to democratic accountability.
Sources & References:
- Wikipedia: Shomrim (Neighborhood Patrol)
- DOJ: Jacob Daskal Sentencing
- Advocate: Taj Patterson Settlement
- Wikipedia: Charles Hynes Controversies
- Jerrold Nadler on Shomrim
#JacobDaskal #TajPatterson #CharlesHynes #EricAdams #SimchaFelder #JerroldNadler #HeshyTischler #Shomrim #BrooklynNews #PoliticalInfluence #CommunityPolicing #CivilianPatrols
